ESPN: “Open Competition” at QB


From a story posted this morning: “sources told ESPN’s Wendi Nix that coach Mike McCarthy will announce Monday he’s holding an open competition between Favre and Aaron Rodgers for the starting quarterback position.”

Rodgers said: “I’m a competitor. I’m going to compete/ This isn’t going to be easy. It’s going to be a dogfight. And I know if they do open it up to competition, not a lot of people give me a chance, but I believe in myself and I’m going to be the best I can be and let coach decide from there.”

Interesting point today on Sirius NFL Radio.  Randy Cross and Shannon Sharpe, broadcasting from Falcons training camp in Flowery Branch, Georgia, (should they practice somewhere more, well, manly, like Stone Mountain?), suggested that Rodgers should beat out Favre to start the season.  Close paraphrase of Sharpe: “There’s a difference between training and working out.  Brett Favre has been working out.”

We may be a long way from that point.  It’s possible the Packers could find something wrong with Favre at his physical today at noon CST and put him on the physically unable to perform list, at least for the short term.  (I think such a move would be stupid unless there is a significant health problem.  It’ll look like the time-wasting ploy it is.)  Or he could be traded before tomorrow AM.

But if Favre is still a Packer tomorrow and if there is an open competition, he’ll win it.  He would have been league MVP if Tom Brady hadn’t played last year.  He was SI’sSportsman of the Year.  The man is a beast — even at 38.

And if you think there’s been an outcry about the situation thus far, imagine what it would be if Rodgers “won” the competition against the first-ballot Hall of Fame QB.


2 Responses to “ESPN: “Open Competition” at QB”

  1. PackerBelle Says:

    While I think it likely Favre would win, I think there is a chance he doesn’t. For one thing Favre hasn’t been doing the off-season conditioning/training that he has done the past three years. He doesn’t know the new players, he doesn’t know how the offense has changed and it wasn’t that long ago that we had that 4-12 season and he played like crap.

  2. Kirk Roebuck Says:

    that 4-13 season was an anomoly—no running game, weak defense, poor receivers (the go to guy got hurt in the 1st qtr of game 1-out for the season. Aside from Driver-no other quality guys). As for new players—c’mon–the offense won’t be changed personnel wise from last year and maybe a couple new guys will make the team.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: